Methodology
How the tools are ranked
Six criteria, each with a weight and a written rule for every score. Anyone can re-check a score against the vendor page it came from, and get the same total.
Last reviewedThe formula
Each criterion is scored 0, 1, 2 or 3. A tool's total is the sum of weight × score ÷ 3 across the six criteria, rounded to the nearest whole number, so a perfect tool scores 100. Ties are listed alphabetically. Nothing else moves a tool up or down: no reviews, no ratings, no traffic data.
| Criterion | Weight | 3 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engine coverage How many answer engines does the cheapest paid plan track, without add-ons? | 25% | Six or more engines included | Four or five engines included | One to three engines included | The engines tracked are not listed publicly |
| API and MCP access Can you pull the visibility data into your own scripts and AI agents? | 20% | Both an API and an MCP server on a plan with a public price | One of the two on a plan with a public price | Only on Enterprise, or as an add-on with no public price | Not stated for this product |
| Reporting and exports Can you get the numbers out to the people who need them? | 15% | Exports plus a BI connector (Looker Studio or similar) on a plan with a public price | Exports, shareable reports or full raw data access on a plan with a public price | Exports only on Enterprise, or not detailed for this product | No exports or reports |
| Pricing transparency Can you know what it costs before talking to sales? | 15% | Every plan has a public price | Self-serve plans are priced; the top tier is custom | Only a free trial is public; paid plans are custom | No public pricing |
| Measurement and optimisation Does it only measure citations, or can it help change them? | 15% | Measures, and makes or drafts changes itself (content, pages, site files) | Measures, and recommends changes or audits the site | Measures only | Does not measure AI answers |
| Cost to start What does the first paid month cost? | 10% | A free plan, or a paid plan under $100 a month | $100 to $299 a month | $300 a month or more | No public paid price |
How each criterion was checked
Engine coverage · 25%
Read from the vendor's pricing page for the cheapest paid plan with a public price that lists its engines. Where no paid plan has a public price, the free trial is scored. Paid add-on engines are noted, not counted.
API and MCP access · 20%
Read from the pricing page and the vendor's API and MCP documentation. A company-wide API that is not stated to serve this product's AI visibility data scores zero.
Reporting and exports · 15%
Read from the pricing page's plan table and the product's feature pages.
Pricing transparency · 15%
Read from the vendor's pricing page on the review date.
Measurement and optimisation · 15%
Read from the product's feature pages. A tool that writes content, edits pages or manages crawler files scores 3; recommendations and audits alone score 2.
Cost to start · 10%
The cheapest monthly price on the vendor's pricing page, billed monthly.
Why these weights
Engine coverage carries the most weight (25%) because a tool that doesn't read the engine your buyers use can't tell you anything about it. It is counted on the cheapest paid plan, because that is where most teams start, and many tools keep engines for higher tiers.
API and MCP access (20%) decides whether the numbers can leave the tool: into your own reports, a warehouse, or an AI agent that acts on them.
Reporting, pricing transparency and optimisation (15% each) cover getting results to the people who need them, knowing the cost before a sales call, and whether the tool only measures citations or also helps change them.
Cost to start (10%) matters least: a cheap plan that tracks the wrong engines is not a bargain.
What we don't score: answer accuracy, data freshness and support quality. They matter, but they can't be checked from public pages, and we won't publish a number we can't show the source for. Test them in a trial.
Every tool's scores
Hover a score for its reason, or open a tool for the reasons and the source pages.
| Tool | Engines 25% | API / MCP 20% | Reporting 15% | Pricing 15% | Optimisation 15% | Entry cost 10% | Total |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Otterly.AI | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 82 |
| AthenaHQ | 3 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 77 |
| Peec AI | 1 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 73 |
| Goodie | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 67 |
| Letter | 0 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 65 |
| Ahrefs Brand Radar | 3 / 3 | 0 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 60 |
| Scrunch | 2 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 60 |
| Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit | 2 / 3 | 0 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 2 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 57 |
| Profound | 1 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 1 / 3 | 3 / 3 | 0 / 3 | 40 |
1. Otterly.AI · 82/100
- Engines 2/3: Four engines included on Lite, the cheapest paid plan.
- API / MCP 3/3: API and MCP both on Standard, a plan with a public price.
- Reporting 3/3: Exports on all plans and a Data Studio connector from Standard.
- Pricing 2/3: Lite, Standard and Premium are priced publicly; Enterprise is custom.
- Optimisation 2/3: Audits and recommendations; it does not make the changes.
- Entry cost 3/3: Lite costs $29 a month.
Sources: Otterly.AI pricing, Otterly.AI API docs, Otterly.AI MCP
2. AthenaHQ · 77/100
- Engines 3/3: Eleven engines on Starter, the cheapest paid plan.
- API / MCP 1/3: API only as a paid add-on with no public price; MCP not stated.
- Reporting 2/3: CSV export on Starter; BI connectors only on Enterprise.
- Pricing 2/3: Essential and Starter priced publicly; Enterprise is custom.
- Optimisation 3/3: A content optimisation agent and crawler file management act on the site.
- Entry cost 3/3: A free Essential plan.
Sources: AthenaHQ pricing
3. Peec AI · 73/100
- Engines 1/3: Three models at once on Starter, the cheapest paid plan.
- API / MCP 3/3: MCP on every plan and API from Pro, both with public prices.
- Reporting 3/3: CSV on all plans and a Looker Studio connector on Advanced.
- Pricing 2/3: Starter, Pro and Advanced priced publicly; Enterprise is custom.
- Optimisation 2/3: Gap analysis and recommended actions; full content generation is not stated.
- Entry cost 3/3: Starter costs $95 a month.
Sources: Peec AI pricing, Peec AI MCP
4. Goodie · 67/100
- Engines 2/3: Five engines on Core, the cheapest paid plan.
- API / MCP 2/3: MCP on every plan; the API only on Enterprise.
- Reporting 1/3: Exports only on Enterprise.
- Pricing 2/3: Core and Pro priced publicly; Enterprise is custom.
- Optimisation 3/3: Writes content and repairs llms.txt and sitemaps.
- Entry cost 2/3: Core costs $295 a month.
Sources: Goodie pricing, Goodie MCP
5. Letter · 65/100
- Engines 0/3: The engines it reads are not listed on its public pages, so it scores zero here until they are.
- API / MCP 3/3: API, CLI and MCP on every plan, from $25 a month.
- Reporting 2/3: Full data through the API and MCP; no CSV export or BI connector listed.
- Pricing 2/3: Hobbyist to Enterprise are priced publicly with per-token rates; a Custom plan is quoted on request.
- Optimisation 3/3: Opens pull requests that change the site: fixes, structured data, new pages.
- Entry cost 3/3: Hobbyist costs $25 a month, and every account starts with 1,000 free tokens.
Sources: Letter pricing, Letter API docs, Letter agents.md
6. Ahrefs Brand Radar · 60/100
- Engines 3/3: Six engines on the $199 Index, the cheapest plan that lists its engines.
- API / MCP 0/3: Neither the API nor the MCP page says it serves Brand Radar data.
- Reporting 1/3: Exports for Brand Radar are not detailed on its page.
- Pricing 2/3: Prices are public, but which models the $50 tier includes is not stated.
- Optimisation 2/3: Shows citation gaps and AI bot traffic; does not make changes.
- Entry cost 3/3: Custom Prompts start at $50 a month.
Sources: Ahrefs Brand Radar, Ahrefs SEO MCP
7. Scrunch · 60/100
- Engines 2/3: Four engines on Core, the cheapest paid plan.
- API / MCP 1/3: API and MCP on Enterprise only.
- Reporting 1/3: Looker Studio only on Enterprise.
- Pricing 2/3: Core priced publicly; Enterprise is custom.
- Optimisation 3/3: Page optimisations, content generation and Agent Pages change what agents read.
- Entry cost 2/3: Core costs $250 a month.
Sources: Scrunch pricing
8. Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit · 57/100
- Engines 2/3: Four engines in prompt tracking on the $99 plan.
- API / MCP 0/3: Neither the API nor the MCP is stated to serve AI visibility data.
- Reporting 2/3: CSV, PDF and white-label reports; no BI connector stated for the toolkit.
- Pricing 2/3: The toolkit is priced publicly; bundle prices are not shown on its page.
- Optimisation 2/3: Recommendations and a site audit; does not make changes.
- Entry cost 3/3: $99 a month.
Sources: Semrush AI Visibility Toolkit KB, Semrush AI visibility data
9. Profound · 40/100
- Engines 1/3: No paid plan has a public price, so it is scored on the trial: three engines.
- API / MCP 1/3: API on Enterprise only; the MCP's plan is not stated.
- Reporting 1/3: Exports on Enterprise only.
- Pricing 1/3: Only the trial is public; the paid plan is custom.
- Optimisation 3/3: AI Marketer researches and writes content.
- Entry cost 0/3: No public paid price.
Sources: Profound pricing, Profound REST API, Profound MCP
Found a score that's out of date?
Vendors change plans often. If a pricing page now says something different from a score's reason, the vendor page is right and the score is stale until the next review. The date at the top of this page is when every tool was last checked.